[altq 427] Re: Altq-2.1 and rsvp tools link errors

["Cambria, Mike" <mcambria@lucent.com>]

		Let me try this again without MS outlook helping me format
the message <g>  Hopefully, this will be formatted better.

		>>   I guess you just had old object files.  Try "make
clean".

		I tried "make clean", no luck.

		>>  The rsvp package uses "log()" for logging messages.  The
function is
		>>  defined in rsvp_debug.c.

		I saw that log() exists in rsvp_debug.c

		What I see the problem as it that the "calls" to OUT0, OUT1
etc. translate to calls to log(), which translate to calls to log_write()
via the rsvpd Makefile (after applying the altq patches).  The log_write()
function is defined in altq-2.1/altqd/altqd.c

		The problem is that the rsvp tools (in the rel4.2a4/tools
directory) do not have an obj/lib to link against to resolve log_write()
calls.

		>>  As you pointed out, this name conflicts with the
logarithm function
		>>  name in the math library, and could have nasty side
effects if you
		>>  want to use the math library.
		>>  So, I modified Makefile to rename log() to log_write()
by C
		>>  preprocesser to avoid the conflict.
		>>  If you compile rsvp_debug.c, the original log() function
should be
		>>  compiled as log_write().


Are you saying that the log() calls made in rsvp_debug.c are meant to become
log_write() calls and that the log_write() function defined in the file
altq-2.1/altqd/altq.c is not used?

I can live with that, especially since the rsvp distribution was built to
use its own log() call.  However, in either case I have the following
problems:

1)	the linker still does not resolve log_write() calls to either
altqd/altq.c(log_write) nor rsvpd/rsvp_debug.c(log)
2)	the logarithm function call to log() in rsvpd_specs.c(math_log) is
now translated to log_write(), when in fact the logarithm call is needed.

Thanks,
MikeC


		Cambria, Mike wrote:
		> Hi,
		> 
		> I've installed altq-2.1 on FreeBSD-3.4-Release as well as
RSVP
		> (rsvpd.rel4.2a4-1.tar) from ISI as instructed in the
rsvpd-kit directory.
		> After applying the patch as instructed in the README, I
get link errors in
		> the tools directory.  Altq itself and rsvpd (with the api
programs in the
		> apitools directory) work.
		> 
		> The link errors result from the definition of log as
log_write.  Did I
		> missed something?  Did I screw something up?  I know I can
work around these
		> problems, but do others see the same thing?  I so, I
wanted to call it to
		> your attention.  If I am the only one, I will start
looking for what I did
		> wrong.
		> 
		> The first case looks like it is simply the log() function
being redefined
		> from the logarithm lib call to the log_write call.
		> 
		> The second case is altq defining where logging is to be
done.  However, altq
		> never patched this function into the rsvp distribution.
The function
		> log_write does exist, in altqd.c, but doesn't end up in
libaltq (which rsvpd
		> does link against.)
		> 
		> The errors are shown below:
		> 
		> bash-2.03# make
		> ../bin/loader gcc -g -Wall -I../rsvpd -DRSVP_DIAG
-L../rsvpd -o rstat
		> rstat.o -lutil -lrsvp -lm
		> ../rsvpd/libutil.a(rsvp_specs.o): In function `math_log':
		> /usr/local/rel4.2a4/rsvpd/rsvp_specs.c(.text+0x251e):
undefined reference to
		> `log_write'
		> ../rsvpd/libutil.a(rsvp_print.o): In function
`rsvp_print_pkt':
		> /usr/local/rel4.2a4/rsvpd/rsvp_print.c:123: undefined
reference to
		> `log_write'
		> /usr/local/rel4.2a4/rsvpd/rsvp_print.c:126: undefined
reference to
		> `log_write'
		> /usr/local/rel4.2a4/rsvpd/rsvp_print.c:128: undefined
reference to
		> `log_write'
		> /usr/local/rel4.2a4/rsvpd/rsvp_print.c:136: undefined
reference to
		> `log_write'
		>
../rsvpd/libutil.a(rsvp_print.o):/usr/local/rel4.2a4/rsvpd/rsvp_print.c:138:
		> more undefined references to `log_write' follow
		> *** Error code 1
		> 
		> 
		> Thanks,
		> MikeC
		>